On the second Tuesday of the season, Tillman Thomas had nearly sold out of produce. Working the Thomas Produce tent with his wife of 45 years, Judy, he told the Anna Maria Island Sun, "Today was really good and I'm running out of stuff." Thomas has sold tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, avocados, citrus and herbs at Anna Maria's Tuesday market since it was a city-hosted event at City Pier Park. He has now worked it at three different sites.
The market moved twice after the storms, and its core vendors moved with it. The Anna Maria Community Farmers Market at Roser Church is a different organization from the city market it replaced. It is run by volunteers, it runs later into spring, and it has about three times as many tents. Its produce anchors are the same vendors who opened the original market, and newer tents fill in around them.
Three sites since 2018, and the market grew at each one
Anna Maria's market started as a trial in March 2018, opening on a stormy day with four vendors at City Pier Park. In later seasons it ran every Tuesday, weather permitting, from October until early or mid-May, and it grew to a dozen or more vendors, most of whom came back each year. The city's vendor document for the last full season at the park listed Tuesdays from Oct. 10, 2023, through May 7, 2024, from 8:30 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Then Hurricanes Helene and Milton hit. After Helene in late September 2024, City Pier Park became a staging area for utility and recovery crews. In late October, the U.S. Postal Service set up a temporary post office under the park's shade sail, and in late November that office moved into a large trailer next to the sail. The Sun reported that the trailer kept the market from using its old space.
The following table shows how the market changed after that.
| Season | Site | Vendors reported |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 debut | City Pier Park, city-hosted | 4 at opening, later a dozen or more |
| 2024–25 | The Center of Anna Maria Island, 407 Magnolia Ave. | 28 at the Jan. 14, 2025 opening |
| 2025–26 | Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave. | 39 at the Oct. 7, 2025 opening |
| 2026–27 | Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave. | About 40 weekly, with a cap of 43 and a wait list |
Devinne "Dev" Whittaker made each of those moves happen. She had been a vendor at the city market during the 2023-24 season. As The Center's volunteer market coordinator, she organized a larger market on The Center's soccer fields starting Jan. 14, 2025. It needed a special event permit from the city commission. Mayor Mark Short told the Sun that the city's only involvement was reviewing that permit. The market got through the season after the storms with 28 vendors and ran through May 27.
Why the market didn't go back to the park
The temporary post office at City Pier Park closed on Oct. 4, 2025, and the regular office at 101B South Bay Blvd. reopened two days later. The market opened its season at Roser Church on Oct. 7, 2025, one day after that.
The Center had approved the move well before then. Its board minutes from Aug. 25, 2025, describe the Roser site as offering "better access/parking." The Sun's report on the first Roser market describes the layout. Vendors set up between the main church building and Lake La Vista, and their tents line the parking lot travel lanes, which serve as wide walkways. According to the Sun's Oct. 20 report, parking is usually plentiful because the church property has several lots.
Whittaker said the space is now full. "We are full of vendors and we have a wait list. We've got 40 vendors and I max out at 43. More than half of my vendors have been with me since day one," she told the Sun during the second week of this season. On the market's opening day at Roser last year, the Sun listed Milagro's Produce among the vendors dating back to the city's first season in 2018.
Who's under the tents this season
The 2026–27 season opened on a rainy Tuesday, Oct. 6. The Center of Anna Maria Island and Roser Church present the market, and Whittaker manages it. The original produce vendors are still there, and newer food tents have opened next to them.
Produce vendors from the original market
- Thomas Produce. Tillman Thomas has sold at the Anna Maria market since the City Pier Park years, offering tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, avocados, citrus and fresh herbs.
- Milagros Produce. Milagros has also been at the market since its first year as a city event. Tony Martinez ran the well-stocked tent on Oct. 13 and called it, jokingly, "Number one produce in America."
The bakers
- Ted's Breads. Whittaker and her fiancé, Ted Louloudes, run this tent, and Ted's Breads is also sold inside The Center. The menu includes miche, Ted's signature sourdough wheat bread, plus cookies and scones.
- Spare Kitchen. Michael Calvino bakes biscuits at the market throughout the day, using organic flour and local buttermilk. Flavors include plain, chocolate chip, sweet potato and rosemary garlic, and the sausage biscuit uses his father's recipe.
One family, three tents
- Sol Sipsters. Sisters Olivia and Grace Schoditsch serve coffee, coffee drinks and matcha green tea. This is their second year next to Spare Kitchen.
- Banana Bums. Their mother runs this tent on the other side of them, selling homemade frozen banana whip.
First-season vendors
- Hermano's Chicken Salad. Lazaro Suayero was in his first year at the market on Oct. 13. He makes several kinds of chicken salad with pasture-raised chicken and Cuban seasonings, packaged fresh at 2 a.m. "The dill pickle is our number one seller," he told the Sun.
- Black Circle Coffee. Brian Nagy's coffee business launched in Sarasota in February, and Oct. 13 was his first market day in Anna Maria. Some of his coffees are named after songs by the jam band Phish.
Made on the island
- Manatee Pottery. Holmes Beach resident Eileen Van Lieshout is in her third season at the market with handmade mugs, bowls, small trinket dishes and pottery ornaments. "I make everything myself from clay and everything's inspired by where we are," she said.
- AMI Turtle Watch. Volunteer Joanie Derry runs a table with a large stuffed turtle that promotes the Adopt-a-Nest program. She sells turtle-themed items and gives the proceeds to the program.
Other tents sell fresh juices, meat and poultry, pickles, microgreens, fish spread, clothing, wellness goods, jewelry, local art and dog treats, and massages are offered on site. A different musician plays each week. Trevor Bystrom played on Oct. 13, and Albert Donadi was scheduled for Oct. 20.
Planning a Tuesday around it
The schedule is longer than the one at City Pier Park. The city market ran until early or mid-May. The Center's market page lists an October-to-May season, and the Sun reports this season continues through the end of May. The details for a visit:
- When: Tuesdays, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., weather permitting. The city market opened at 8:30 a.m. in its last season at the park.
- Where: Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave. Tents are set up between the church and Lake La Vista.
- Parking: Use the church lots, which the Sun describes as generally plentiful.
- Timing: Thomas Produce was running low on Oct. 13, so the produce tables offer the most choice earlier in the day.
The Center, the market's other presenting partner, also has events on its calendar this season. It is hosting beach cleanups on Nov. 14 and Dec. 12. The 25th annual Lester Family Fun Day is Saturday, Dec. 5, from 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. at The Center, 407 Magnolia Ave., where the market spent its season after the storms.
Whittaker explained why she keeps organizing the market each season: "I just love building a friendly community where people can gather."
The parts of Anna Maria that people use every week, like a Tuesday market a short walk down Pine Avenue, are part of what a home here is worth. If you'd like to know how your home compares in today's market, the two partners at Renne' Rupp can tell you. Request a Free Home Valuation.